← Sobeck. · a take
On the Eighth Circuit's pause of Minnesota's AI-nudification ban

The Statute Handed xAI Its Defense on a Plate

*The injunction everyone's arguing about isn't the alarming part — it's that Minnesota banned a class of tools instead of the act of targeting a person, and roughly twenty states copied the same flaw.*

The Eighth Circuit has paused Minnesota's ban on AI nudification — software that strips clothes onto real people's photos — while it weighs xAI's constitutional challenge. Coverage (CBS News Minnesota, India Today) has framed this as a fight between a tech company and the state. It isn't. It's a fight the state picked with itself, and lost before the briefs were filed.

Here's the structural problem. Minnesota's law — like the roughly twenty near-identical bans other states passed in the same legislative season, most cut from the same template — regulates a *class of tools* rather than the *act of targeting a person*. That distinction is the whole ballgame under the First Amendment. The moment a statute bans software by category, it sweeps in expressive and non-abusive uses along with the abusive ones, and that breadth is exactly what triggers strict scrutiny. xAI didn't find a loophole. The statute built one and handed it over, gift-wrapped. A law aimed at the conduct — creating and distributing nonconsensual sexualized images of an identifiable person — would be a far harder target, because the harm and the regulated act would match. Ban the tool instead, and the challenger's case writes itself.

Give Attorney General Keith Ellison his strongest version, because he has one, and it's true: this stuff destroys people. A teenage girl wakes up to find her classmates passing around a fake nude of her; the image migrates across platforms faster than any takedown request can travel. Ellison is right about the harm and wrong that this particular statute survives strict scrutiny. Both things can be true at once, and pretending they can't — defending the product-ban framing because the cause is just — is how you lose the cause.

The quiet catastrophe isn't the injunction. It's what falls with the ban: the statutory remedies victims actually use.

Because when the Eighth Circuit rules — and I'd bet it strikes this, with the chain following through the other states — what collapses isn't just the prohibition. It's the victim's fast path. Under these statutes, a targeted person has a specific, quick remedy: takedown, damages, fees. Strip the statute and they're back to general tort law, where the image circulates for weeks before a complaint even gets drafted and filed. The people the law was written for end up worse protected than before it existed — the legislative equivalent of demolishing the bridge while building it.

The fix isn't louder defense of a framing that's about to lose. It's rewriting these laws around identifiable victims: aim at the targeting, not the tool, and embed the victim's remedies so deeply in the statute that they don't fall when the tool-ban does. States that copy their neighbors' statutes in a panic season get their neighbors' flaws. States that draft for the victim get a law that survives the scrutiny it was always going to face. Twenty legislatures now get to find out which kind they were.

← all takes